lady_windermere: Spike profile (Kiss Already)
I was over at [livejournal.com profile] metafandom today, just to find out what is going on. It was largely depressing, and it seems fandom has had an ugly week. Not the Buffy!Verse as such, but it has effected people in the verse. I do not want to stir up the shark invested waters. If you want to know what is going on, I suggest you go over to that community, where others have made posts about the subject far better than I can.

While I was there, I did find an interesting post concerning feedback, and why do fanfic writers and artists post what they have created by [livejournal.com profile] sidewalk_doctor (who is not on my friends list), entitled "moar fandom meta, bitches", the link is here.

I was quite interested in the post. Yes, I adore feedback, I admit it. I will always respond to it, because it has made me happy.....but am I therefore an attention whore?

I would never complain if I don't get feedback, in fact I have often posted knowing full well I would be lucky to get a comment to the story. It is an unusual pairing, or deals with a subject that most people don't want to read. It doesn't stop me from posting. I post so that I might have an archive for the work. If someone else enjoys it, and lets me know, wonderful, and gives me a glow, Would I run away crying because I didn't get the feedback I thought the work deserved. No!

The majority of people in all fandoms are lurkers, so even if you have a flist of several hundreds, you would be very lucky to get even 30 comments.....and even then, quite a few could be someone having a chat with you in comments.

Others have an OTP, and will not read anything that is outside that. I will not force you to read, if you do not force me to write. If my muse wants to try other pairings, or other genres then I will. If you don't want to read, that is great. I got the story off my chest.

So I really don't think I am writing for the feedback. I have no intention of becoming an author, and sending my work off to be published. Writing fanfic is a hobby, and if I only want to write a couple of 100 word drabbles for a while, then that is what I will do. So no pressure on me to write, no pressure on anyone to read, or leave comments.

Guess that was all I wanted to add to the original post.
lady_windermere: Spike profile (Default)
Just mulling over feedback, and when we get lots, then hardly any. Ok a lot if it might be to do with our pairings, some, such as Spangel, being more popular than others.

I would guess that only about 20% of people who read a fic, or look at a manip, icon, banner leave feedback. It may seem, with less feedback that the fandom is dying, but I just do not believe this at all. The fandom is alive and strong, just that a high percentage of people are lurkers. Whither that is because they do not have the confidence to leave feedback, do not like what they have read/seen, or have read/seen some of our work, and don't like it and never venture to give it another go, only they would know.

It took me quite some time to leave feedback when I first entered into the fandom, and read fanfic. At that time I read Spuffy, and some of the writers had such a superiour attitude when replying to feedback, I stopped for a while. I only started again when I read Spangel, and the replies to my feedback were so nice I contunued to give more feedback.

Even getting a rec doesn't mean you get lots of feedback either. I have been reced, and only got about two items of feedback from it, or none at all. While I love gettting a rec, I do not look forward to lots of feedback from it, otherwise I would be disappointed.

Feedback is a funny thing, sometimes you get lots, others hardly any. Not something to be counted on, and certainly doesn't indicate the strengh of the fandom. There are a lot of quiet people out there, busy reading, looking at artwork, but not saying anything.

Profile

lady_windermere: Spike profile (Default)
lady_windermere

June 2011

S M T W T F S
   1234
567891011
12131415161718
19202122232425
26 27282930  

Syndicate

RSS Atom

Most Popular Tags

Style Credit

Expand Cut Tags

No cut tags